Surprise, surprise that swiftlet farmers are willing to relocate even if given new sites. Most likely these are new bh where there is not many birds. The established one will certainly find it impossible to move without losing all the birds.
Jackie
**********************************************************************************
Wednesday September 15, 2010
The Star
OPERATORS of swiflet farms in the heritage enclave in George Town are willing to relocate if the authorities identify a new location for them.
Association for Swiftlet Nest Industries (ASNI) president Carole Loh said there should be proper planning just like the relocation of hawkers and squatters.
“We are only requesting that we’re treated fairly in the relocation process,” she said when contacted yesterday.
She was commenting on the statement by state executive councillor Chow Kon Yeow that the state government would hold a meeting next week to work out a mechanism to implement the three-year grace period for swiftlet farms to move out of the George Town heritage enclave.
Chow said the meeting would involve ASNI, Penang Heritage Trust and other related organisations.
He was quoted as saying it was up to the state government to decide when the grace period would begin.
The issue of relocation arose after the National Council for Local Government had agreed on Sept 3 for swiftlet farms to move out of the Penang and Malacca heritage enclaves.
Loh said the operators were awaiting details on the relocation plan.
“It is almost impossible to move out without affecting the swiftlets as putting the birds in cages and moving them out is not the right way.
“Swiftlets will return to their nests as soon as they are released from the cage,” she said.
Showing posts with label world heritage status. Show all posts
Showing posts with label world heritage status. Show all posts
Wednesday, September 15, 2010
Wednesday, September 8, 2010
Move ruffles feathers
The response from ASNI to the opening salvo from the National Council for Local Government. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to understand that you cannot relocate the swiftlets. One way is perhaps to "buy out" the swiftlet farm owners - renovation cost plus RM1000 per nest in the birdhouse? Even that might not solve the problem because a lot of owners are very emotionally attached to their birds and the birdhouse eg. yours truly.
Again I asked the question. Is UNESCO asking for the birdhouse to be moved out ? afterall the birdhouse were there when the World Heritage status was awarded to Georgetown and Melaka.
Jackie
*********************************************************************************
Wednesday September 8, 2010
The Star
By ANDREA FILMER
andrea@thestar.com.my
GEORGE TOWN: The Association of Swiftlet Nests Industry (ASNI) Penang branch is crying foul over the ban on swiftlet farming in the Penang and Malacca heritage enclaves.
Branch president Carole Loh (pic) claimed the association was getting “mixed signals” over the issue as a Heritage Zone Swiftlet Premises Regulation Committee had been set up at the national level to regulate swiftlet operators in heritage zones.
“The last meeting of the committee was held in Kuala Lumpur on Aug 23 and it was chaired by Heritage Commissioner Prof Emeritus Datin Zuraina Majid.
“ASNI is disappointed and confused that an announcement has been made (on the banning of swiftlet far-ming in heritage areas) when this committee is still in existence to evaluate swiftlet operators on a case-by-case basis,” said Loh, who is also the ASNI national secretary.
She claimed that the members of the regulation committee had already been selected, with some being present at the meeting.
“The Veterinary Department, Penang and Malacca Town and Country Planning departments, George Town World Heritage Incorporated, Malacca World Heritage Office and ASNI are members and most were represented.
“It was also decided that the Agriculture Ministry and Information, Communication and Culture Ministry would be included in the committee,” she said.
On Thursday, Deputy Prime Minister Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin announced that the National Council for Local Government had decided that swiftlet farming would be prohibited in Penang and Malacca heritage enclaves.
Muhyiddin added, however, that a three-year grace period would be given to current operators.
The Penang Government subsequently announced that a meeting would be held after Hari Raya to work out a mechanism to implement the grace period for swiftlet farms to move to agriculture areas.
Loh reiterated that it would be difficult for swiftlet operators to move.
“There is no way for us to move. The birds roam freely and build nests in the pre-war houses.
“We do not feed them or confine them,” Loh said.
Again I asked the question. Is UNESCO asking for the birdhouse to be moved out ? afterall the birdhouse were there when the World Heritage status was awarded to Georgetown and Melaka.
Jackie
*********************************************************************************
Wednesday September 8, 2010
The Star
By ANDREA FILMER
andrea@thestar.com.my
GEORGE TOWN: The Association of Swiftlet Nests Industry (ASNI) Penang branch is crying foul over the ban on swiftlet farming in the Penang and Malacca heritage enclaves.
Branch president Carole Loh (pic) claimed the association was getting “mixed signals” over the issue as a Heritage Zone Swiftlet Premises Regulation Committee had been set up at the national level to regulate swiftlet operators in heritage zones.
“The last meeting of the committee was held in Kuala Lumpur on Aug 23 and it was chaired by Heritage Commissioner Prof Emeritus Datin Zuraina Majid.
“ASNI is disappointed and confused that an announcement has been made (on the banning of swiftlet far-ming in heritage areas) when this committee is still in existence to evaluate swiftlet operators on a case-by-case basis,” said Loh, who is also the ASNI national secretary.
She claimed that the members of the regulation committee had already been selected, with some being present at the meeting.
“The Veterinary Department, Penang and Malacca Town and Country Planning departments, George Town World Heritage Incorporated, Malacca World Heritage Office and ASNI are members and most were represented.
“It was also decided that the Agriculture Ministry and Information, Communication and Culture Ministry would be included in the committee,” she said.
On Thursday, Deputy Prime Minister Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin announced that the National Council for Local Government had decided that swiftlet farming would be prohibited in Penang and Malacca heritage enclaves.
Muhyiddin added, however, that a three-year grace period would be given to current operators.
The Penang Government subsequently announced that a meeting would be held after Hari Raya to work out a mechanism to implement the grace period for swiftlet farms to move to agriculture areas.
Loh reiterated that it would be difficult for swiftlet operators to move.
“There is no way for us to move. The birds roam freely and build nests in the pre-war houses.
“We do not feed them or confine them,” Loh said.
Saturday, September 4, 2010
end game for swiftlet farmers in Georgetown
This is going to be tough. All eyes will be on this one. A potentially explosive situation that needs cool heads.
the swiftlets birdhouse were already there before Penang was awarded its World Heritage status. It is suppose to benefit the people there but in this case would it become a curse for the birdhouse farmers? Is UNESCO asking for the birdhouse to be removed for George Town to retain its heritage status?
The birdhouse owners feels that they have helped maintain the old vacant and idled buildings and stopped them from falling apart by putting the money in to renovate them into birdhouse. Now they are told that they are a nuisance by the councils.
If they are asked to move out then the repercussion would be that other councils around the country would use that as a precedent and ask the birdhouse owners in their area to move out of town. It will affect some 100,000 birdhouse owners and their families. This is going to be a real political mine field.
Jackie Chow
Saturday September 4, 2010
Swiftlet farms to shift out of city
GEORGE TOWN: The state government will hold a meeting after Hari Raya to work out a mechanism to implement the three-year grace period for swiftlet farms to move out of the heritage enclave here.
State Local Government and Traffic Management Committee chairman Chow Kon Yeow said that the meeting would involve the Association of Swiftlet Nests Industry (ASNI), Penang Heritage Trust and related organisations.
“We will work out a mechanism to implement the decision by the council. It is also up to us to decide when to begin the grace period,” he said.
It was reported yesterday that the National Council for Local Government came up with the grace period after it decided to prohibit swiftlet farming in Penang and Malacca heritage enclaves.
Asked about possible legal action by ASNI against the state for enforcing the eviction, he said it could take whatever action it wanted.
“The farms will be moved to agricultural areas but we will discuss this first at the meeting,” he said.
the swiftlets birdhouse were already there before Penang was awarded its World Heritage status. It is suppose to benefit the people there but in this case would it become a curse for the birdhouse farmers? Is UNESCO asking for the birdhouse to be removed for George Town to retain its heritage status?
The birdhouse owners feels that they have helped maintain the old vacant and idled buildings and stopped them from falling apart by putting the money in to renovate them into birdhouse. Now they are told that they are a nuisance by the councils.
If they are asked to move out then the repercussion would be that other councils around the country would use that as a precedent and ask the birdhouse owners in their area to move out of town. It will affect some 100,000 birdhouse owners and their families. This is going to be a real political mine field.
Jackie Chow
Saturday September 4, 2010
Swiftlet farms to shift out of city
GEORGE TOWN: The state government will hold a meeting after Hari Raya to work out a mechanism to implement the three-year grace period for swiftlet farms to move out of the heritage enclave here.
State Local Government and Traffic Management Committee chairman Chow Kon Yeow said that the meeting would involve the Association of Swiftlet Nests Industry (ASNI), Penang Heritage Trust and related organisations.
“We will work out a mechanism to implement the decision by the council. It is also up to us to decide when to begin the grace period,” he said.
It was reported yesterday that the National Council for Local Government came up with the grace period after it decided to prohibit swiftlet farming in Penang and Malacca heritage enclaves.
Asked about possible legal action by ASNI against the state for enforcing the eviction, he said it could take whatever action it wanted.
“The farms will be moved to agricultural areas but we will discuss this first at the meeting,” he said.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
